N.I.H. Says It Is Not Giving Up in Patent Fight with Moderna
The dispute has potential implications for the vaccine’s long-term availability and billions in future profits.
The N.I.H. says it isn’t giving up in its patent fight with Moderna.
A vial of the Moderna vaccine.Credit…Bess Adler for The New York Times
Published Nov. 10, 2021Updated Nov. 11, 2021, 9:02 a.m. ET
The National Institutes of Health is prepared to aggressively defend its assertion that its scientists helped invent a crucial component of the Moderna coronavirus vaccine — including taking legal action if government lawyers deem it necessary, the agency’s director said on Wednesday.
Moderna’s vaccine, which appears to provide the world’s best defense against Covid-19, grew out of four years of collaboration with research scientists at the N.I.H.’s Vaccine Research Center. The New York Times reported on Tuesday that the company has blocked three N.I.H. researchers from being named on a key patent application.
Much more than scientific recognition is at stake. If federal researchers were named as co-inventors in the patent, the government would have a nearly unfettered right to license the Moderna vaccine to other manufacturers, which could expand access to it in poorer nations and bring the government millions in revenue.
The agency’s director, Dr. Francis Collins, declined to be interviewed. But speaking to Reuters in advance of a virtual health conference hosted by the news service, he made clear that the N.I.H., the government’s biomedical research agency, was not backing down.
“I think Moderna has made a serious mistake here in not providing the kind of co-inventorship credit to people who played a major role in the development of the vaccine that they’re now making a fair amount of money off of,” he told Reuters. He added: “But we are not done. Clearly this is something that legal authorities are going to have to figure out.”
A spokeswoman for Dr. Collins, Renate Myles, stopped short of saying that the dispute was headed to court.
“Dr. Collins simply stated that N.I.H. is not giving up on our claim that N.I.H. is a co-inventor on the mRNA technology used in the Moderna COVID-19 vaccine, but defers to legal authorities on how this might be resolved,” she said. By legal authorities, she said, Dr. Collins meant government lawyers.
The three government researchers that N.I.H. has been trying to get named alongside Moderna employees as co-inventors worked with company scientists on the genetic sequence at the core of how the vaccine triggers an immune response.
As the virus began to spread in January 2020, scientists at N.I.H. and Moderna worked in parallel over a single weekend to zero in on the gene for the virus’s spike protein. Both teams independently identified the same gene.
The State of Vaccine Mandates in the U.S.
A growing number of employers, universities and businesses are now issuing some form of a vaccine requirement. Here’s a closer look.
Private Sector: The Biden administration set Jan. 4 as the deadline for large companies to mandate vaccinations or start weekly testing of their workers, but a federal appeals court temporarily blocked the rule.Federal Government: A mandate for the vast majority of federal workers applies to employees of the executive branch, including the White House and all federal agencies and members of the military.City Workforces: Some major cities — New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago — are requiring municipal workers to get vaccinated.Schools: California issued a mandate for all educators and plans to add the vaccine as a requirement to attend school. New York City has a mandate for teachers and staff in public schools.Colleges: More than 400 colleges and universities require students to be vaccinated.Hospitals: Many medical centers are requiring employees to get vaccinated. Mandates for health care workers in California and New York State compelled thousands of holdouts to receive the shots.
Moderna has rebuffed the government’s efforts. In a July filing with the United States Patent and Trademark Office, Moderna said it had “reached the good-faith determination that these individuals did not co-invent” the component.
Moderna’s chief executive, Stephane Bancel, said on Wednesday that the company was in confidential discussions with the N.I.H. and would communicate publicly if a resolution to the dispute is reached.
“What we just need to work out with the N.I.H. is who are the inventors. And there are very clear rules set out by the law about inventorship, and they are very important to protect the patent,” Mr. Bancel said at a virtual conference put on by Wired magazine.
Moderna has received $1.4 billion from the federal government to develop its vaccine and another $8.1 billion to provide the country with half a billion doses. It is also earning billions in profits from supply deals.
Biden administration officials have said they lack the legal authority to require the company to share its vaccine recipe and technical know-how with manufacturers who could produce it at a lower cost for poorer countries.
After Dr. Collins’s comments were reported, a Moderna spokeswoman, reiterated that the company had concluded that only Moderna scientists came up with the sequence that powers the vaccine.